diff --git a/public/pages/Indices/containers/Indices/Indices.tsx b/public/pages/Indices/containers/Indices/Indices.tsx
index 21c04f967..c8dc06fab 100644
--- a/public/pages/Indices/containers/Indices/Indices.tsx
+++ b/public/pages/Indices/containers/Indices/Indices.tsx
@@ -131,7 +131,10 @@ export class Indices extends MDSEnabledComponent<IndicesProps, IndicesState> {
     try {
       const { indexService, history } = this.props;
       const queryObject = this.getQueryObjectFromState(this.state);
-      const queryParamsString = queryString.stringify({ ...queryObject, dataSourceLabel: this.state.dataSourceLabel });
+      const queryParamsString = queryString.stringify({
+        ...queryObject,
+        ...(this.state.multiDataSourceEnabled ? { dataSourceLabel: this.state.dataSourceLabel } : {}),
+      });
       history.replace({ ...this.props.location, search: queryParamsString });
 
       const getIndicesResponse = await indexService.getIndices({
diff --git a/public/pages/ManagedIndices/containers/ManagedIndices/ManagedIndices.tsx b/public/pages/ManagedIndices/containers/ManagedIndices/ManagedIndices.tsx
index 01f0bafb7..233d19b7e 100644
--- a/public/pages/ManagedIndices/containers/ManagedIndices/ManagedIndices.tsx
+++ b/public/pages/ManagedIndices/containers/ManagedIndices/ManagedIndices.tsx
@@ -247,7 +247,10 @@ export class ManagedIndices extends MDSEnabledComponent<ManagedIndicesProps, Man
     try {
       const { managedIndexService, history } = this.props;
       const queryObject = ManagedIndices.getQueryObjectFromState(this.state);
-      const queryParamsString = queryString.stringify({ ...queryObject, dataSourceLabel: this.state.dataSourceLabel });
+      const queryParamsString = queryString.stringify({
+        ...queryObject,
+        ...(this.state.multiDataSourceEnabled ? { dataSourceLabel: this.state.dataSourceLabel } : {}),
+      });
       history.replace({ ...this.props.location, search: queryParamsString });
 
       const getManagedIndicesResponse = await managedIndexService.getManagedIndices({