From 232f0b0a982561108303b0db9ad8277ec8a1465c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Christian Chiarcos Date: Tue, 4 Jun 2024 13:17:00 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Create minutes-2025-06-04.md --- doc/wrapup/minutes-2025-06-04.md | 59 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 59 insertions(+) create mode 100644 doc/wrapup/minutes-2025-06-04.md diff --git a/doc/wrapup/minutes-2025-06-04.md b/doc/wrapup/minutes-2025-06-04.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cb5d1f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/doc/wrapup/minutes-2025-06-04.md @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +attending: +- MI,MP,CC (aka, the writing team) + +# diagram updates + +morph:Paradigm => morph:InflectionClass +morph:paradigm => morph:inflectionClass +morph:InflectionType => morph:InflectionSlot +morph:inflectionType => morph:inflectionSlot + +morph:grammaticalMeaning holds (also) between morph:InflectionSlot and morph:GrammaticalMeaning + +Keep morph:replacement with anyURI in the vocabulary, drop morph:Replacement. + +# additional notes + +Finite State Morphology is beyond Morph (but could be a superclass of morph:InflectionSlot) + +Chiarcos et al. (2020) showed how the sequence of states in finite state morphology can be modelled using morph:InflectionSlot and the morph:next property. In the current OntoLex-Morph specification, this functionality is not foreseen because finite state automata are more general than linguistic morphology and should be dealt with in a designated vocabulary. However, once such a vocabulary is proposed, morph:InflectionSlot could be interpreted as a subclass of finite states in this vocabulary. + +Note that different formalisms can be used to implement morph:Replacement. As an example, Ionov and Rosner (2023) used regular expression replacements. The exact definition of morph:Replacement is, however, broader and relevant beyond morphology, so that it should be dealt with in a designated vocabulary. + +- Keep morph:replacement with anyURI in the vocabulary, drop morph:Replacement. +- Non-normative example using xyz:Replacement with xyz:source and xyz:target. + +# timeline + +- adding Matteo as co-editor +- Matteo (June, maybe July, not August, again Sep) + - small examples for each section (we can help with RDF modelling) + - working directly on github? keep structure, work on text and examples as input to Max +- Max: (starting end of June) + - would re-write completely, copying and pasting from scratch + - end of June: draft outline by Max + - early July: call on outline (to be set up by Max) + - then call an division of parts / populate by copying and pasting +- Christian: (upon request) + - focus on FrAC, provide feedback on overall coherence + +# current document structure [to be improved upon] + + Purpose and Scope + Morphological Segments [static part] + morph:Morph + morph:GrammaticalMeaning + morph:morphophonologicalRelation + morph:baseForm + Morphological Rules [dynamic part] + morph:example + morph:Replacement + Word Formation + morph:WordFormationRule + morph:WordFormationRelation + Inflection + morph:Paradigm + morph:InflectionType + morph:InflectionRule + morph:baseType +