feat: vip challenge #76
Conversation
WalkthroughRecent changes encompass updates across multiple modules and repositories, focusing on API enhancements, refactoring, and bug fixes. Notable updates include modifications to Changes
Poem
Tip AI model upgrade
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (2)
api/libcompiler.dylibis excluded by!**/*.dylibapi/libmovevm.dylibis excluded by!**/*.dylib
Files selected for processing (1)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (54 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (7)
precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (7)
54-56: Constants for Error CodesThe constants
EINVALID_CLAIMABLE_PERIOD,EINVALID_CHALLENGE_PERIOD, andEINVALID_CHALLENGE_STAGEare well-named, following the naming convention for error codes in the module. They provide clear indications of their purpose.
71-71: Default Challenge Period DefinedThe constant
DEFAULT_CHALLENGE_PERIODis set to10080, which corresponds to 7 days (assuming the unit is minutes). This is a typical duration for a challenge or review period in governance systems. The comment is clear and helpful.
Line range hint
74-103: Review ofModuleStoreStructThe
ModuleStorestruct centralizes important configuration and state information. It includes fields for stages, vesting periods, ratios, and tables for data storage. The use oftable::Tableforchallengesandstage_datasuggests an efficient lookup and storage mechanism for potentially large datasets. The struct is comprehensive and seems well-structured for its intended use in managing VIP operations.
104-106: Agent Data Struct ReviewThe
AgentDatastruct holds anagentaddress and anapi_uri, which are essential for operations that involve external data interactions. The inclusion of theapi_uriis particularly notable as it allows dynamic interaction endpoints, which can be crucial for decentralized applications.
144-153: Executed Challenge Data StructureThe
ExecutedChallengestruct is well-designed to encapsulate all necessary details about a challenge, including identifiers, descriptive fields (title,summary), and execution metadata (api_uri,new_agent,merkle_root,execution_time). This struct will be critical for tracking and auditing challenge executions.
928-1008: Functionexecute_challengeReviewThis function handles the execution of a challenge, ensuring that only authorized entities can trigger it (
check_chain_permission). It performs several checks, such as stage progression and challenge timing, before updating the system state. The function is complex but appears to be well-structured with clear error handling and state management. However, detailed unit tests would be crucial to ensure its robustness and security.
238-248: EventExecuteChallengeEventReviewThe
ExecuteChallengeEventis comprehensive, including all relevant details about the executed challenge. This is crucial for transparency and auditability in the system. The event captures both identifiers and descriptive information, ensuring that external systems or interfaces can effectively utilize this data.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (1)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (55 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (3)
precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (3)
54-56: Constants for Error Codes and Default ValuesThe addition of error codes for claimable period, challenge period, and challenge stage is appropriate to handle specific error scenarios. The
DEFAULT_CHALLENGE_PERIODis set to 10080, which corresponds to 7 days (in minutes), aligning with the typical weekly cycle used in many systems. This is a sensible default for a challenge period.Also applies to: 71-71
Line range hint
74-102: Struct Modifications and Additions
- ModuleStore: The addition of
challenge_periodandchallengestable supports the new challenge functionality. It's crucial to ensure that these fields are appropriately utilized in the logic to manage challenges and periods effectively.- AgentData: This new struct with
agentandapi_urifields seems to be designed for managing agent-specific data, which is a good practice for separating concerns.- Snapshot: Addition of
create_timeandupsert_timehelps in tracking the lifecycle of snapshots, which is beneficial for audit and tracking purposes.- ExecutedChallenge: This new struct captures detailed information about executed challenges, which is essential for maintaining a transparent and traceable system for challenge management.
Overall, the struct modifications and additions seem well-thought-out and align with the objectives of enhancing the challenge mechanism.
Also applies to: 104-106, 121-123, 144-153
928-1008: Functionexecute_challengeReviewThis function is central to the new challenge mechanism. It checks permissions, validates stages, and handles the creation and updating of challenge-related data. A few points to consider:
- The permission check using
check_chain_user_permissionensures that only authorized users can execute challenges, which is crucial for security.- The assertion that the current stage must be greater than the challenge stage (
module_store.stage > challenge_stage) is a good safeguard to prevent retrospective challenges which could disrupt the system state.- The use of
make_challenge_table_keyfor creating a unique key for each challenge ensures that challenges are stored uniquely and can be retrieved efficiently.- Updating the
agentDataand snapshot upon successful challenge execution is a critical operation and seems to be handled correctly.This function is well-implemented with appropriate checks and balances. It is a good example of solid smart contract function design.
| @@ -337,7 +391,7 @@ module initia_std::vip { | |||
| fun check_agent_permission(agent: &signer) acquires ModuleStore { | |||
| let module_store = borrow_global<ModuleStore>(@initia_std); | |||
| assert!( | |||
| signer::address_of(agent) == module_store.agent, | |||
| signer::address_of(agent) == module_store.agentData.agent, | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Check Agent Permission
The function check_agent_permission uses a direct comparison of the agent's address with the stored address in ModuleStore. This is a straightforward and effective way to ensure that the action is being performed by the authorized agent. However, consider adding more detailed error messages or logging to provide clearer feedback in case of unauthorized access attempts.
- error::permission_denied(EUNAUTHORIZED)
+ error::permission_denied(EUNAUTHORIZED, "Unauthorized access attempt by non-agent")Committable suggestion was skipped due to low confidence.
djm07073
force-pushed
the
feat/vip-challenge
branch
from
06bf04e to
b0d5c07
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (1)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (55 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (3)
precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (3)
54-56: Constants Review: Error Codes and Default SettingsThe constants
EINVALID_CLAIMABLE_PERIOD,EINVALID_CHALLENGE_PERIOD, andEINVALID_CHALLENGE_STAGEare well-named, clearly indicating their purpose related to error handling in challenge periods. TheDEFAULT_CHALLENGE_PERIODis set to10080, which presumably represents minutes in a week, aligning with the typical duration for a challenge period. Ensure these constants are used consistently across the codebase.Also applies to: 71-71
Line range hint
74-102: Structs Review: Modifications and Additions
ModuleStorehas been significantly modified to includechallenge_periodand a new table forchallenges. This aligns with the new functionality to handle challenges.AgentDatais a new struct that includesagentandapi_uri, which seems to be used for identifying and interacting with external agents.ExecutedChallengeis another new struct that captures details about executed challenges, including metadata liketitleandsummary, which enhances traceability and auditability of challenges.Ensure that the new fields in these structs are properly initialized wherever these structs are instantiated or modified.
Also applies to: 104-106, 121-123, 144-153
238-248: Event Review:ExecuteChallengeEventThe
ExecuteChallengeEventlogs key data points related to the execution of a challenge, includingbridge_id,stage,title,summary,api_uri,new_agent,merkle_root, andexecution_time. This comprehensive data capture is excellent for auditability and tracking. Ensure that this event is emitted at the correct places in the logic flow to accurately reflect the operations performed.
[APROVED]
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/weight_vote.move (1)
Line range hint
1258-1268: Use of hardcoded test data in functional code.The function
init_testuses hardcoded test data (DEFAULT_VIP_L2_CONTRACT_FOR_TEST) directly within its body. This is generally not recommended as it reduces the flexibility and reusability of the test function. Consider parameterizing this data or retrieving it from a configuration file or environment variable to enhance the test's adaptability and maintainability.- string::utf8(DEFAULT_VIP_L2_CONTRACT_FOR_TEST), + string::utf8(test_contract_data),And modify the function signature to:
- fun init_test(chain: &signer): coin::MintCapability { + fun init_test(chain: &signer, test_contract_data: vector<u8>): coin::MintCapability {
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (2)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (77 hunks)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/weight_vote.move (3 hunks)
Files not summarized due to errors (1)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move: Error: Message exceeds token limit
Additional comments not posted (7)
precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/weight_vote.move (1)
1226-1227: Add documentation for the constant.The constant
DEFAULT_VIP_L2_CONTRACT_FOR_TESTis added for testing purposes, but there is no accompanying documentation to explain its purpose or usage context. This can make maintenance difficult, especially for new developers or external contributors.precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/vip/vip.move (6)
54-56: New Error Constants Defined AppropriatelyThe newly added error constants (
EINVALID_CLAIMABLE_PERIOD,EINVALID_CHALLENGE_PERIOD,EINVALID_CHALLENGE_STAGE) are well-defined and seem to cover specific scenarios related to challenge periods and stages. Ensure these constants are used appropriately in error handling throughout the module.
71-71: Default Challenge Period SetThe constant
DEFAULT_CHALLENGE_PERIODis set to10080, which corresponds to 7 days (in minutes). This aligns with typical governance challenge periods, providing a reasonable default value.
Line range hint
80-106: StructModuleStoreandAgentDataEnhancementsThe addition of
challenge_periodandagentDatato theModuleStorestruct is crucial for the new challenge functionalities. TheAgentDatastruct, which includesagentandapi_uri, is well-defined. Ensure theapi_uriis validated where it is used to prevent any potential security issues from malformed URLs.
101-101: New Table for ChallengesThe introduction of a
challengestable to storeExecutedChallengeinstances is a key part of managing challenge data. The structAgentDatais appropriately designed to handle agent-specific data, which is critical for operations that require permissions.Also applies to: 104-106
145-154: StructExecutedChallengeAdequately DefinedThe
ExecutedChallengestruct captures all necessary details about a challenge, such asbridge_id,stage,title,summary,api_uri,new_agent,merkle_root, andexecution_time. This comprehensive data collection is essential for tracking and auditing challenges.
1614-1621: Function to Update Challenge PeriodThe
update_challenge_periodfunction allows governance to update the challenge period. It correctly checks chain permissions before proceeding with the update. This function is vital for adaptability in governance processes.
* feat: minitswap in house arb * update precompile * update dependency * fix test * enforce minium cache capacity * fix clippy * fix clippy * feat: add ibc_op_init_metadata on arb batch response * fix: fix `get_fully_recovered_pool_amounts` and use pool size * add some break condition * update binary --------- Co-authored-by: beer-1 <147697694+beer-1@users.noreply.github.com>
…ovevm into feat/vip-challenge
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (6)
api/libcompiler.aarch64.sois excluded by!**/*.soapi/libcompiler.dylibis excluded by!**/*.dylibapi/libcompiler.x86_64.sois excluded by!**/*.soapi/libmovevm.aarch64.sois excluded by!**/*.soapi/libmovevm.dylibis excluded by!**/*.dylibapi/libmovevm.x86_64.sois excluded by!**/*.so
Files selected for processing (17)
- .github/workflows/lint.yml (1 hunks)
- Cargo.toml (1 hunks)
- Makefile (1 hunks)
- api/bindings_compiler.h (1 hunks)
- crates/compiler/src/built_package.rs (1 hunks)
- crates/e2e-move-tests/src/tests/args.rs (2 hunks)
- crates/vm/src/move_vm.rs (1 hunks)
- lib_test.go (1 hunks)
- libcompiler/bindings_compiler.h (1 hunks)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/account.move (7 hunks)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/coin.move (2 hunks)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/managed_coin.move (2 hunks)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/stableswap.move (12 hunks)
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/staking.move (1 hunks)
- precompile/modules/minitia_stdlib/sources/account.move (7 hunks)
- precompile/modules/minitia_stdlib/sources/coin.move (2 hunks)
- precompile/modules/minitia_stdlib/sources/managed_coin.move (2 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (12)
- .github/workflows/lint.yml
- Cargo.toml
- Makefile
- api/bindings_compiler.h
- crates/compiler/src/built_package.rs
- crates/e2e-move-tests/src/tests/args.rs
- libcompiler/bindings_compiler.h
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/account.move
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/coin.move
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/managed_coin.move
- precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/staking.move
- precompile/modules/minitia_stdlib/sources/managed_coin.move
Additional context used
golangci-lint
lib_test.go
17-17: could not import github.com/initia-labs/movevm/api (-: # github.com/initia-labs/movevm/api
api/callbacks.go:7:10: fatal error: bindings.h: No such file or directory
7 | #include "bindings.h"
| ^~~~~~~~~~~~
compilation terminated.)(typecheck)
Additional comments not posted (18)
precompile/modules/minitia_stdlib/sources/coin.move (2)
61-64: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
79-82: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
precompile/modules/minitia_stdlib/sources/account.move (8)
35-38: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
46-58: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
Line range hint
70-89: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
117-120: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
128-131: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
139-142: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
150-153: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
161-164: LGTM!The formatting changes improve readability without altering the logic.
lib_test.go (1)
58-58: Verify the appropriateness of the new memory allocation values.The memory allocation for the VM has been increased significantly. Ensure that the new values are appropriate for the expected workload.
crates/vm/src/move_vm.rs (2)
88-88: LGTM!The change enforces a default cache capacity for modules and scripts, ensuring that the
MoveVMis initialized with a minimum cache size.
93-101: LGTM!The change ensures that the cache capacities for modules and scripts are not below the specified threshold, providing a safeguard against insufficient cache sizes.
precompile/modules/initia_stdlib/sources/stableswap.move (5)
75-85: LGTM!The addition of
UpdateSwapFeeEventandUpdateAnnEventallows tracking updates to swap fees and ANN values, enhancing the observability and auditability of changes to these parameters.
174-191: LGTM!The addition of
get_swap_simulation_given_outprovides a way to simulate swaps based on the desired output amount, which can be useful for users who want to determine the required input amount to obtain a specific output.
268-294: LGTM!The addition of
spot_priceprovides a way to determine the current price of a pool based on a fixed swap amount, which can be useful for price discovery and analysis.
Line range hint
1036-1107: LGTM!The modifications to
swap_simulationensure that the swap simulation accurately reflects the impact of fees and adjusts the offer amount accordingly, improving the accuracy of the simulation results.
Line range hint
1174-1238: LGTM!The inclusion of the swap operation in the
end_to_endtest ensures that the swap functionality is tested in a comprehensive manner, covering the entire pool lifecycle.
execute_challenge: execute a challenge regarding the reward result, only be executed by governance.Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Bug Fixes
Refactor
Dependencies
clrudependency version inCargo.toml.Chores
movefmtcommand inMakefilefor more specific file pattern formatting..github/workflows/lint.yml.Tests