Post-Judging QA

[thebrittfactor]

1. Please post feedback about specific findings on the relevant issue in this repo.
2. Post a comment in this discussion linking to all findings you've commented on, along with any general feedback for the judge.

The judge for this contest is @alex-ppg.

Both the Validation repo and the Findings repo will be open to wardens with the SR role, for the purposes of post-judging QA.

• All post-judging QA requests must be posted in this Github Discussion in the findings repo.
• QA and Gas reports closed by Validators (i.e. not added to the findings repo) are NOT eligible.

Reminders

• Please keep your comments as fact-based as possible.
• C4 judges have final authority in determining validity and severity.
• Please link to specific issues and don't try to start discussions here.
• Please familiarize yourselves with our Good Citizen Policy.

Thank you!

[CrystallineButterfly]

Hey @alex-ppg Thank you for judging 🙏

Please can you do a quick review on issues #197 and #243 to be safe, as both my pocs show the issues detailed,

All the best- K👽

[stalinMacias]

Hey @alex-ppg
I added a comment on issue #49 . Please let me know your thoughts about my comments.

[rodiontr]

Hi @alex-ppg. Left a comment on #116. Thanks for judging.

[Shubh0412]

Hello @alex-ppg Thank you for judging this contest.
Please find time to look at comments on issues #109 & validation-repo #48

[Shubh0412]

Hello @alex-ppg, could you please take a look at a final comment left at issue #48 in validation-repo.

[coffiasd]

@alex-ppg please double check this submission #114

[dontonka]

Hello @alex-ppg, good job cleaning up this contest, I didn't follow it much but at some point I think there was hundreds of finding that seems valid.

Could you check please the following finding:
30 : It didn't make it to the finding repo but I disagree with the validator for his rejection.

Thanks in advance for considering my claim!

[mcgrathcoutinho]

Hey @alex-ppg, thank you for the detailed responses!

I've left my comments on #53.

[mcgrathcoutinho]

Hey @alex-ppg, dropped one last comment on #53.

Thank you for your time!

[nnez]

Hey there @alex-ppg
I left a comment on #19

Please have a look :)

[gesha17]

@alex-ppg

Thanks for judging, I left a comment on #18

Appreciate it if you can have a look.

[whoismxuse]

Hey @alex-ppg thank you for judging.

Left a comment on #79 & #129

Thanks in advance.

[midori-fuse]

Hello, thanks for judging.

I left a comment on #59. Thanks for taking your time.

[KupiaSecAdmin]

Hi @alex-ppg, thanks for judging.
I left comments on #26, #27, #28, and #30.
Thanks.

[Bauchibred]

Thanks for judging @alex-ppg, left two comments: here & here.

[thebrittfactor]

Please note: PJ QA has now closed. No additional comments should be added unless requested by the judge.