Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

[D] D programming language Implementation of Arrow #44515

Closed
kassane opened this issue Oct 23, 2024 · 10 comments
Closed

[D] D programming language Implementation of Arrow #44515

kassane opened this issue Oct 23, 2024 · 10 comments
Assignees
@kassane
Labels
Component: Integration Type: enhancement

Comments

@kassane
Copy link

kassane commented Oct 23, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Describe the enhancement requested

Like Swift and other languages from small communities.
I would like to suggest that the D language (v2) implementation be added to arrow-upstream (or a separate repository as a library).

outdated ref. library: https://github.com/ananis25/darrow
Auto-generated: https://github.com/rostyboost/darrow

Component(s)

Integration
@kou
Copy link
Member

kou commented Oct 24, 2024

Thanks for your suggestion.
We need at least one maintainer/contributor to proceed this. Do you know any candidates for it?

@kassane
Copy link
Author

kassane commented Oct 24, 2024

Do you know any candidates for it?

I will try to do it.

Recently contributing to Apache OpenDAL also for D support.

@kou
Copy link
Member

kou commented Oct 24, 2024

Great!

It seems that https://github.com/ananis25/darrow generates bindings from C header files. But we don't need to do it because Apache Arrow C GLib supports GObject Introspection.
https://gi.readthedocs.io/en/latest/

GObject Introspection provides API related metadata. We can use them instead of parsing C header files.

It seems that there is a D tool for GObject Introspection: https://github.com/gtkd-developers/gir-to-d

Can we use it instead of parsing C header files?

@kassane
Copy link
Author

kassane commented Oct 24, 2024

It seems that there is a D tool for GObject Introspection: https://github.com/gtkd-developers/gir-to-d

Works!

# $PWD =  arrow/d
$ girtod -g ../c_glib.build/arrow-glib/ -i Arrow-1.0.gir -o source
$ girtod -g ../c_glib.build/arrow-glib/ -i ../arrow-dataset-glib/ArrowDataset-1.0.gir -o source
$ girtod -g ../c_glib.build/arrow-glib/ -i ../arrow-flight-glib/ArrowFlight-1.0.gir -o source
tree-ls output 
$ tree .
.
├── README.md
├── dub.sdl
└── source
    ├── arrow
    │   ├── AggregateNodeOptions.d
    │   ├── Aggregation.d
    │   ├── Array.d
    │   ├── ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── ArrayDatum.d
    │   ├── ArraySortOptions.d
    │   ├── AzureFileSystem.d
    │   ├── BaseBinaryScalar.d
    │   ├── BaseListScalar.d
    │   ├── BinaryArray.d
    │   ├── BinaryArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── BinaryDataType.d
    │   ├── BinaryDictionaryArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── BinaryScalar.d
    │   ├── BooleanArray.d
    │   ├── BooleanArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── BooleanDataType.d
    │   ├── BooleanScalar.d
    │   ├── Buffer.d
    │   ├── BufferInputStream.d
    │   ├── BufferOutputStream.d
    │   ├── CSVReadOptions.d
    │   ├── CSVReader.d
    │   ├── CallExpression.d
    │   ├── CastOptions.d
    │   ├── ChunkedArray.d
    │   ├── ChunkedArrayDatum.d
    │   ├── Codec.d
    │   ├── CompressedInputStream.d
    │   ├── CompressedOutputStream.d
    │   ├── CountOptions.d
    │   ├── DataType.d
    │   ├── Date32Array.d
    │   ├── Date32ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Date32DataType.d
    │   ├── Date32Scalar.d
    │   ├── Date64Array.d
    │   ├── Date64ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Date64DataType.d
    │   ├── Date64Scalar.d
    │   ├── Datum.d
    │   ├── DayMillisecond.d
    │   ├── DayTimeIntervalArray.d
    │   ├── DayTimeIntervalArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── DayTimeIntervalDataType.d
    │   ├── DayTimeIntervalScalar.d
    │   ├── Decimal128.d
    │   ├── Decimal128Array.d
    │   ├── Decimal128ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Decimal128DataType.d
    │   ├── Decimal128Scalar.d
    │   ├── Decimal256.d
    │   ├── Decimal256Array.d
    │   ├── Decimal256ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Decimal256DataType.d
    │   ├── Decimal256Scalar.d
    │   ├── DecimalDataType.d
    │   ├── DenseUnionArray.d
    │   ├── DenseUnionArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── DenseUnionDataType.d
    │   ├── DenseUnionScalar.d
    │   ├── DictionaryArray.d
    │   ├── DictionaryDataType.d
    │   ├── DoubleArray.d
    │   ├── DoubleArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── DoubleDataType.d
    │   ├── DoubleScalar.d
    │   ├── EqualOptions.d
    │   ├── ExecuteContext.d
    │   ├── ExecuteNode.d
    │   ├── ExecuteNodeOptions.d
    │   ├── ExecutePlan.d
    │   ├── Expression.d
    │   ├── ExtensionArray.d
    │   ├── ExtensionDataType.d
    │   ├── ExtensionDataTypeRegistry.d
    │   ├── ExtensionScalar.d
    │   ├── FeatherFileReader.d
    │   ├── FeatherWriteProperties.d
    │   ├── Field.d
    │   ├── FieldExpression.d
    │   ├── FileIF.d
    │   ├── FileInfo.d
    │   ├── FileInputStream.d
    │   ├── FileOutputStream.d
    │   ├── FileSelector.d
    │   ├── FileSystem.d
    │   ├── FileT.d
    │   ├── FilterNodeOptions.d
    │   ├── FilterOptions.d
    │   ├── FixedSizeBinaryArray.d
    │   ├── FixedSizeBinaryArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── FixedSizeBinaryDataType.d
    │   ├── FixedSizeBinaryScalar.d
    │   ├── FixedWidthDataType.d
    │   ├── FloatArray.d
    │   ├── FloatArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── FloatDataType.d
    │   ├── FloatScalar.d
    │   ├── FloatingPointDataType.d
    │   ├── Function.d
    │   ├── FunctionDoc.d
    │   ├── FunctionOptions.d
    │   ├── GCSFileSystem.d
    │   ├── GIOInputStream.d
    │   ├── GIOOutputStream.d
    │   ├── HDFSFileSystem.d
    │   ├── HalfFloatArray.d
    │   ├── HalfFloatArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── HalfFloatDataType.d
    │   ├── HalfFloatScalar.d
    │   ├── HashJoinNodeOptions.d
    │   ├── ISO8601TimestampParser.d
    │   ├── IndexOptions.d
    │   ├── InputStream.d
    │   ├── Int16Array.d
    │   ├── Int16ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Int16DataType.d
    │   ├── Int16Scalar.d
    │   ├── Int32Array.d
    │   ├── Int32ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Int32DataType.d
    │   ├── Int32Scalar.d
    │   ├── Int64Array.d
    │   ├── Int64ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Int64DataType.d
    │   ├── Int64Scalar.d
    │   ├── Int8Array.d
    │   ├── Int8ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Int8DataType.d
    │   ├── Int8Scalar.d
    │   ├── IntArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── IntegerDataType.d
    │   ├── IntervalDataType.d
    │   ├── JSONReadOptions.d
    │   ├── JSONReader.d
    │   ├── LargeBinaryArray.d
    │   ├── LargeBinaryArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── LargeBinaryDataType.d
    │   ├── LargeBinaryScalar.d
    │   ├── LargeListArray.d
    │   ├── LargeListArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── LargeListDataType.d
    │   ├── LargeListScalar.d
    │   ├── LargeStringArray.d
    │   ├── LargeStringArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── LargeStringDataType.d
    │   ├── LargeStringScalar.d
    │   ├── ListArray.d
    │   ├── ListArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── ListDataType.d
    │   ├── ListScalar.d
    │   ├── LiteralExpression.d
    │   ├── LocalFileSystem.d
    │   ├── LocalFileSystemOptions.d
    │   ├── MapArray.d
    │   ├── MapArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── MapDataType.d
    │   ├── MapScalar.d
    │   ├── MatchSubstringOptions.d
    │   ├── MemoryMappedInputStream.d
    │   ├── MemoryPool.d
    │   ├── MockFileSystem.d
    │   ├── MonthDayNano.d
    │   ├── MonthDayNanoIntervalArray.d
    │   ├── MonthDayNanoIntervalArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── MonthDayNanoIntervalDataType.d
    │   ├── MonthDayNanoIntervalScalar.d
    │   ├── MonthIntervalArray.d
    │   ├── MonthIntervalArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── MonthIntervalDataType.d
    │   ├── MonthIntervalScalar.d
    │   ├── MutableBuffer.d
    │   ├── NullArray.d
    │   ├── NullArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── NullDataType.d
    │   ├── NullScalar.d
    │   ├── NumericArray.d
    │   ├── NumericDataType.d
    │   ├── ORCFileReader.d
    │   ├── OutputStream.d
    │   ├── PrimitiveArray.d
    │   ├── ProjectNodeOptions.d
    │   ├── QuantileOptions.d
    │   ├── RankOptions.d
    │   ├── ReadOptions.d
    │   ├── ReadableIF.d
    │   ├── ReadableT.d
    │   ├── RecordBatch.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchBuilder.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchDatum.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchFileReader.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchFileWriter.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchIterator.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchReader.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchStreamReader.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchStreamWriter.d
    │   ├── RecordBatchWriter.d
    │   ├── ResizableBuffer.d
    │   ├── RoundOptions.d
    │   ├── RoundToMultipleOptions.d
    │   ├── RunEndEncodeOptions.d
    │   ├── RunEndEncodedArray.d
    │   ├── RunEndEncodedDataType.d
    │   ├── S3FileSystem.d
    │   ├── S3GlobalOptions.d
    │   ├── Scalar.d
    │   ├── ScalarAggregateOptions.d
    │   ├── ScalarDatum.d
    │   ├── Schema.d
    │   ├── SeekableInputStream.d
    │   ├── SetLookupOptions.d
    │   ├── SinkNodeOptions.d
    │   ├── SlowFileSystem.d
    │   ├── SortKey.d
    │   ├── SortOptions.d
    │   ├── SourceNodeOptions.d
    │   ├── SparseUnionArray.d
    │   ├── SparseUnionArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── SparseUnionDataType.d
    │   ├── SparseUnionScalar.d
    │   ├── SplitPatternOptions.d
    │   ├── StreamDecoder.d
    │   ├── StreamListener.d
    │   ├── StrftimeOptions.d
    │   ├── StringArray.d
    │   ├── StringArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── StringDataType.d
    │   ├── StringDictionaryArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── StringScalar.d
    │   ├── StrptimeOptions.d
    │   ├── StrptimeTimestampParser.d
    │   ├── StructArray.d
    │   ├── StructArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── StructDataType.d
    │   ├── StructFieldOptions.d
    │   ├── StructScalar.d
    │   ├── SubTreeFileSystem.d
    │   ├── Table.d
    │   ├── TableBatchReader.d
    │   ├── TableConcatenateOptions.d
    │   ├── TableDatum.d
    │   ├── TakeOptions.d
    │   ├── TemporalDataType.d
    │   ├── Tensor.d
    │   ├── Time32Array.d
    │   ├── Time32ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Time32DataType.d
    │   ├── Time32Scalar.d
    │   ├── Time64Array.d
    │   ├── Time64ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── Time64DataType.d
    │   ├── Time64Scalar.d
    │   ├── TimeDataType.d
    │   ├── TimestampArray.d
    │   ├── TimestampArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── TimestampDataType.d
    │   ├── TimestampParser.d
    │   ├── TimestampScalar.d
    │   ├── UInt16Array.d
    │   ├── UInt16ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── UInt16DataType.d
    │   ├── UInt16Scalar.d
    │   ├── UInt32Array.d
    │   ├── UInt32ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── UInt32DataType.d
    │   ├── UInt32Scalar.d
    │   ├── UInt64Array.d
    │   ├── UInt64ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── UInt64DataType.d
    │   ├── UInt64Scalar.d
    │   ├── UInt8Array.d
    │   ├── UInt8ArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── UInt8DataType.d
    │   ├── UInt8Scalar.d
    │   ├── UIntArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── UTF8NormalizeOptions.d
    │   ├── UnionArray.d
    │   ├── UnionArrayBuilder.d
    │   ├── UnionDataType.d
    │   ├── UnionScalar.d
    │   ├── VarianceOptions.d
    │   ├── WritableFileIF.d
    │   ├── WritableFileT.d
    │   ├── WritableIF.d
    │   ├── WritableT.d
    │   ├── WriteOptions.d
    │   └── c
    │       ├── functions.d
    │       └── types.d
    ├── arrowdataset
    │   ├── CSVFileFormat.d
    │   ├── Dataset.d
    │   ├── DatasetFactory.d
    │   ├── DirectoryPartitioning.d
    │   ├── FileFormat.d
    │   ├── FileSystemDataset.d
    │   ├── FileSystemDatasetFactory.d
    │   ├── FileSystemDatasetWriteOptions.d
    │   ├── FileWriteOptions.d
    │   ├── FileWriter.d
    │   ├── FinishOptions.d
    │   ├── Fragment.d
    │   ├── HivePartitioning.d
    │   ├── HivePartitioningOptions.d
    │   ├── IPCFileFormat.d
    │   ├── InMemoryFragment.d
    │   ├── KeyValuePartitioning.d
    │   ├── KeyValuePartitioningOptions.d
    │   ├── ParquetFileFormat.d
    │   ├── Partitioning.d
    │   ├── PartitioningFactoryOptions.d
    │   ├── Scanner.d
    │   ├── ScannerBuilder.d
    │   └── c
    │       ├── functions.d
    │       └── types.d
    └── arrowflight
        ├── CallOptions.d
        ├── Client.d
        ├── ClientOptions.d
        ├── CommandDescriptor.d
        ├── Criteria.d
        ├── DataStream.d
        ├── Descriptor.d
        ├── DoPutResult.d
        ├── Endpoint.d
        ├── Info.d
        ├── Location.d
        ├── MessageReader.d
        ├── MetadataReader.d
        ├── MetadataWriter.d
        ├── PathDescriptor.d
        ├── RecordBatchReader.d
        ├── RecordBatchStream.d
        ├── RecordBatchWriter.d
        ├── ServableIF.d
        ├── ServableT.d
        ├── Server.d
        ├── ServerAuthHandler.d
        ├── ServerAuthReader.d
        ├── ServerAuthSender.d
        ├── ServerCallContext.d
        ├── ServerCustomAuthHandler.d
        ├── ServerOptions.d
        ├── StreamChunk.d
        ├── StreamReader.d
        ├── StreamWriter.d
        ├── Ticket.d
        └── c
            ├── functions.d
            └── types.d

8 directories, 349 files

@kassane
Copy link
Author

kassane commented Oct 24, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Can we use it instead of parsing C header files?

It's possible. However, need manual fixes, like:
kassane@4bcfed1

Note

c/functions.d changes are affected by --use-runtime-linker

# $PWD = arrow
$ dub test --root=d -f
             Generating test runner configuration 'arrow-d-test-unittest' for 'unittest' (library).
     Pre-gen Running commands for glibd
    Existing package girtod found locally
0 packages fetched, 1 already present, 0 failed
             Building package girtod in /home/kassane/.dub/packages/girtod/0.23.2/girtod/
     Pre-gen Running commands for girtod
    Starting Performing "debug" build using /usr/bin/ldc2 for x86_64.
    Building girtod 0.23.2: building configuration [application]
     Linking girtod
     Running ../../../girtod/0.23.2/girtod/girtod -i src -o generated --use-runtime-linker
copying file [src/gtkd] to [generated/gtkd]
    Starting Performing "unittest" build using /usr/bin/ldc2 for x86_64.
    Building glibd 2.4.3+commit.2.g1546823: building configuration [library]
    Building arrow-d ~master: building configuration [arrow-d-test-unittest]
source/arrow/GIOOutputStream.d(12,8): Error: `OutputStream` matches conflicting symbols:
public class GIOOutputStream : OutputStream
       ^
source/arrow/OutputStream.d(18,8):        class `arrow.OutputStream.OutputStream`
public class OutputStream : ObjectG, FileIF, WritableIF
       ^
../../.dub/packages/glibd/1546823185334c4727d378baf890fa13d9fa4cbd/glibd/generated/gio/OutputStream.d(58,8):        class `gio.OutputStream.OutputStream`
public class OutputStream : ObjectG
       ^
source/arrow/GIOOutputStream.d(55,9): Error: `OutputStream` matches conflicting symbols:
        public this(OutputStream gioOutputStream)
        ^
source/arrow/OutputStream.d(18,8):        class `arrow.OutputStream.OutputStream`
public class OutputStream : ObjectG, FileIF, WritableIF
       ^
../../.dub/packages/glibd/1546823185334c4727d378baf890fa13d9fa4cbd/glibd/generated/gio/OutputStream.d(58,8):        class `gio.OutputStream.OutputStream`
public class OutputStream : ObjectG
       ^
source/arrow/GIOOutputStream.d(76,22): Error: `OutputStream` matches conflicting symbols:
        public OutputStream getRaw()
                     ^
source/arrow/OutputStream.d(18,8):        class `arrow.OutputStream.OutputStream`
public class OutputStream : ObjectG, FileIF, WritableIF
       ^
../../.dub/packages/glibd/1546823185334c4727d378baf890fa13d9fa4cbd/glibd/generated/gio/OutputStream.d(58,8):        class `gio.OutputStream.OutputStream`
public class OutputStream : ObjectG
       ^
source/arrow/LargeListArray.d(138,27): Error: function `DataType arrow.LargeListArray.LargeListArray.getValueType()` does not override any function, did you mean to override `arrow.c.types.GArrowType arrow.Array.Array.getValueType()`?
        public override DataType getValueType()
                          ^
source/arrow/ListArray.d(134,27): Error: function `DataType arrow.ListArray.ListArray.getValueType()` does not override any function, did you mean to override `arrow.c.types.GArrowType arrow.Array.Array.getValueType()`?
        public override DataType getValueType()
                          ^

@cyrusmsk
Copy link

There is also another older implementation: https://github.com/rostyboost/darrow
Also how do you think would be helpful to have a separate bindings for https://github.com/apache/arrow-nanoarrow?
Because it has direct C API and it can be used through ImportC approach probably

@kassane
Copy link
Author

kassane commented Oct 24, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Also how do you think would be helpful to have a separate bindings for https://github.com/apache/arrow-nanoarrow?

For C library, D importC solve (e.g. opendal_c header). However, C++ API does require manual intervention, because the existing bindgens for cpp2d have specific use cases, like cppconv.

Edit: I don't plan to support nanoarrow at the moment.

@kassane kassane mentioned this issue Oct 25, 2024
Open
@kassane
Copy link
Author

kassane commented Oct 25, 2024

It's possible. However, need manual fixes, like

Having made some minor fixes, the biggest issues are linked to multiple inheritance by the auto-generated binding and conflicting members per inherited module.

commit tested: kassane@86c9062

Build: 🆗
Run: ❌

# Arrow-libs: $PWD/build/release
# Arrow-glibs: $PWD/c_glib.build/arrow-glib, $PWD/c_glib.build/arrow-flight-glib, $PWD/c_glib.build/arrow-dataset-glib
$ LD_LIBRARY_PATH=$PWD/c_glib.build/arrow-glib:$PWD/build/release:$PWD/c_glib.build/arrow-flight-glib:$PWD/c_glib.build/arrow-dataset-glib dub test -f --root=d/
             Generating test runner configuration 'arrow-d-test-unittest' for 'unittest' (library).
     Pre-gen Running commands for glibd
    Existing package girtod found locally
0 packages fetched, 1 already present, 0 failed
             Building package girtod in /home/kassane/.dub/packages/girtod/0.23.2/girtod/
     Pre-gen Running commands for girtod
    Starting Performing "debug" build using /home/kassane/zig/ldc2-master/bin/ldc2 for x86_64.
    Building girtod 0.23.2: building configuration [application]
     Linking girtod
     Running ../../../girtod/0.23.2/girtod/girtod -i src -o generated --use-runtime-linker
copying file [src/gtkd] to [generated/gtkd]
    Starting Performing "unittest" build using /home/kassane/zig/ldc2-master/bin/ldc2 for x86_64.
    Building glibd 2.4.3+commit.2.g1546823: building configuration [library]
    Building arrow-d ~master: building configuration [arrow-d-test-unittest]
     Linking arrow-d-test-unittest
     Running arrow-d-test-unittest 
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x23f1b7) [0x65499791d1b7]
/usr/lib/libc.so.6(+0x3d1d0) [0x7a751a9151d0]
/home/kassane/arrow/c_glib.build/arrow-glib/libarrow-glib.so.1800(_Z20garrow_array_get_rawP12_GArrowArray+0xa) [0x7a751acb466a]
/home/kassane/arrow/c_glib.build/arrow-glib/libarrow-glib.so.1800(garrow_array_get_length+0x1e) [0x7a751acb522e]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0xf3db0) [0x6549977d1db0]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0xf3aeb) [0x6549977d1aeb]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x23f1f8) [0x65499791d1f8]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x24c417) [0x65499792a417]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x24c949) [0x65499792a949]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x24c3bc) [0x65499792a3bc]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x24393f) [0x65499792193f]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x23f0a4) [0x65499791d0a4]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x246a1b) [0x654997924a1b]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x246947) [0x654997924947]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x24679d) [0x65499792479d]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0x14aec2) [0x654997828ec2]
/usr/lib/libc.so.6(+0x25e08) [0x7a751a8fde08]
/usr/lib/libc.so.6(__libc_start_main+0x8c) [0x7a751a8fdecc]
/home/kassane/arrow/d/arrow-d-test-unittest(+0xf3995) [0x6549977d1995]
Error Program exited with code -11

$ c++filt _Z20garrow_array_get_rawP12_GArrowArray
garrow_array_get_raw(_GArrowArray*)

@kou
Copy link
Member

kou commented Oct 26, 2024

Great!

Let's work on this step-by-step. How about supporting only arrow-glib as the first step? We can add support for other modules such as arrow-flight-glib later.

Could you open a PR for it? I'll try it too.

In general, we want to avoid changing auto generated files. We want to improve the upstream like you did for gtkd-developers/gir-to-d#45 instead.

FYI: We also use the approach for the C# Parquet bindings: #41886
e.g.: gircore/gir.core#1077

@github-actions github-actions bot mentioned this issue Oct 26, 2024
Closed
@kassane
Copy link
Author

kassane commented Feb 23, 2025 •
edited
Loading

Kymorphia/gid provides initial support using the official Arrow GIR files.

@kassane kassane closed this as not planned Won't fix, can't repro, duplicate, stale Feb 23, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@kassane kassane

Labels
Component: Integration Type: enhancement
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
3 participants
@kou @cyrusmsk @kassane