reviewer-checklist.md

General

• The README gave a good overview and includes
  • a title;
  • a description of about 300 words (including context, story);
  • keywords;
  • temporal coverage;
  • geographic coverage (MRGIDs from MarineRegions);
  • if applicable: Taxonomic coverage (AphiaIDs from WoRMS)
  • what datasets does this product uses? List the IMIS dasids, and/or DOIs from datasets not listed in IMIS.
  • Is this product a continuation of an older product? Does it uses another product? If yes, please provide its IMIS dasid.

Authorship and citation

• There is citation information.
  • The citation format in the README is: Last name, First name. Year. Title.
• There is authors, and contact information.

Code

• There are guidelines for re-running the code.
• I was able to run the code.
• The output did not change, or changed according to expectation (e.g. more occurrences).

Data

• Datasets are documented with e.g. datascpice.
• I was able to read in and use datasets.

Upkeep

• The README included a lifecycle badge or description.
• There is a changelog.

Further review comments 😸