Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Problem with interval_tree copy constructor and assignment #39

Closed
feldroop opened this issue Oct 21, 2024 · 2 comments
Closed

Problem with interval_tree copy constructor and assignment #39

feldroop opened this issue Oct 21, 2024 · 2 comments

Comments

@feldroop
Copy link

Hello, thank you for creating this nice library.

I noticed that the copy constructor for the interval_tree causes a compiler error.

I am using GCC 12.3 on x86_64-linux-gnu and CMake 3.28.2.

This code does not compile (copy assignment also doesn't):

using namespace lib_interval_tree;
interval_tree_t<int> intervals{};
interval_tree_t<int> intervals2(intervals);

This is the error I get:

[build] In file included from MY_CODE/intervals.hpp:7,
[build]                  from MY_CODE/intervals.cpp:1:
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp: In instantiation of ‘lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<IntervalT, tree_hooks>::node_type* lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<IntervalT, tree_hooks>::copy_tree_impl(node_type*, node_type*) [with IntervalT = lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>; tree_hooks = lib_interval_tree::hooks::regular; node_type = lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>]’:
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp:935:25:   required from ‘lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<IntervalT, tree_hooks>& lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<IntervalT, tree_hooks>::operator=(const lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<IntervalT, tree_hooks>&) [with IntervalT = lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>; tree_hooks = lib_interval_tree::hooks::regular]’
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp:918:22:   required from ‘lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<IntervalT, tree_hooks>::interval_tree(const lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<IntervalT, tree_hooks>&) [with IntervalT = lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>; tree_hooks = lib_interval_tree::hooks::regular]’
[build] MY_CODE/intervals.cpp:103:46:   required from here
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp:1471:29: error: no matching function for call to ‘lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>::node(lib_interval_tree::interval_tree<lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, lib_interval_tree::hooks::regular>::node_type*&, const lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>::interval_type*)’
[build]  1471 |                 auto* cpy = new node_type(parent, root->interval());
[build]       |                             ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp:379:9: note: candidate: ‘lib_interval_tree::node<numerical_type, interval_type, derived>::node(node_type*, interval_type) [with numerical_type = int; interval_type_ = lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>; derived = void; node_type = lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>; interval_type = lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>]’
[build]   379 |         node(node_type* parent, interval_type interval)
[build]       |         ^~~~
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp:379:47: note:   no known conversion for argument 2 from ‘const lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>::interval_type*’ {aka ‘const lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>*’} to ‘lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>::interval_type’ {aka ‘lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>’}
[build]   379 |         node(node_type* parent, interval_type interval)
[build]       |                                 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp:353:11: note: candidate: ‘constexpr lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>::node(const lib_interval_tree::node<int, lib_interval_tree::interval<int, lib_interval_tree::closed>, void>&)’
[build]   353 |     class node
[build]       |           ^~~~
[build] (...)/interval-tree/26a47086beff5cd25c72fab5acc709bac57b4494/include/interval-tree/interval_tree.hpp:353:11: note:   candidate expects 1 argument, 2 provided

The move constructor and move assignment do not cause issues.

@5cript
Copy link
Owner

5cript commented Oct 21, 2024

I will take a look at this as soon as I am able.

@5cript
Copy link
Owner

5cript commented Oct 21, 2024

This will be fixed in: #40
Embarrassing test gap that you found. I broke this somewhere around 2.X.Y

@5cript 5cript closed this as completed Oct 21, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants